Note: this post is not finished – Last edited Nov. 16 by Bethany Velarde As a senior, I’m balancing writing final papers for my courses this semester with the transition to post-graduation life and the uncertainties inherent in that like graduates before me. This semester I’m taking 22 credits while I try to graduate a […]
Serial 2 Present for Duty Response
My view before listening to the entirety of Serial 2 was that I knew little of the American military presence in Afghanistan. I did not know what soldiers experienced on the ground, how captured Taliban are treated by the U.S. government or how captured U.S. soldiers are treated by terrorist organizations (the closest thing I read about it before was Unbroken by Laura Hillenbrand, about an American POW), how long Bowe was in Afghanistan or what the U.S. was doing in Afghanistan now. I lacked the most basic awareness of Bowe’s case or what his recovery meant for American and international politics and the war in Afghanistan.
Serial 2 Thorny Politics Response
Listening to the podcast now, I want to know the answer to my original question. In the penultimate episode of Serial 2, narrator Sarah Koenig hones in on this politicization of Bowe’s rescue, and what that means for military strategies, political compromises and diplomatic negotiations today.
Serial 2 Trade Secrets Response
After listening to Episode 9, I found out that peace talks with the Taliban have hit setback after setback, and some have seemed especially calculated and intentional. For example, the leaks about the U.S.-Taliban peace talks; when the Afghanistan High Peace Council head and former president Burhanuddin Rabbani was assassinated, right before international peace talks were set to begin in late 2011. Then in 2013, the Afghan government, the U.S., the Qataris and the Taliban are working to allow the Taliban to have a political office in Qatar. Then the Taliban violates the ground rules and labels the office as the ‘Islamic Emirate.’ Karzai is upset, and the Taliban feel humiliated over a misunderstanding. Talks halt again.
Serial 2 Hindsight, Part 1 and 2 Response
In the Hindsight episodes, Sarah Koenig explores the idea that Bowe was unfit for military service. In Part 1, Bowe’s prior military history, his entering the U.S. Coast Guard and being discharged on a psychological diagnosis after a breakdown, is told. In Part 2, Bowe’s admittance to the U.S. Army after his previous medical and mental health based discharge is scrutinized, as well as the diagnosis of Bowe having Schizotypal personality disorder. By the end of Hindsight, Parts 1 and 2, all of this history is applied to Bowe walking off of OP Mest, and how his irrational and potentially dangerous behavior could be explained.
Serial 2 The Captors Response
In the fourth episode of Serial 2, Bowe’s treatment by the Taliban is contrasted with that of David Rohde, an American journalist. After last episode, where Bowe’s attempts to escape during the first year are documented, The Captors focuses on how he is treated and held for the following four years.
Serial 2 Escaping Response
From the third episode, Escaping, it looks like Bowe Bergdahl is at least 60 (and probably much more than that) away from FOB Sharana, in Pakistan. Wherever he is held, especially in Pakistan, it is far from any metropolis, and far from U.S. personnel. In the third episode of the Serial 2, the listener begins to feel a sense of the vast aloneness Bowe felt in captivity, and two escapes he attempted in the first year of captivity. I was much harsher in my opinion of Bowe when I had only heard the first part of the story, but now hearing about this first year and how much he suffered, he was still a young, twenty-three year old guy, not much older than me. I do not think the media treatment of Bowe, the sensationalization of him was at all deserved.
Serial 2 DUSTWUN Response
This is the first in a series of posts about Serial 2, a podcast focused on the war in Afghanistan. It centered around Bowe Bergdahl, and I wrote responses to the podcast for my first semester International Relations major-required course, Introduction to World Politics. We learned about the international state system, and challenges to international […]
